Thursday, October 7, 2010

From Williams College: Students for Sensible Drug Policy



Steve Luther, President of the Students for a Sensible Drug Policy  chapter at Williams College, writes:

"I started a discussion on a Williams online forum about marijuana vs. alcohol and the justification for legalization.  It has so far been a very civil and well-reasoned debate":
http://wso.williams.edu/discuss/comments.php?DiscussionID=2691

Here is Steve's post, which spearheaded  a lively, intelligent discussion.


"On any given weekend, a portion of the student body will be smoking pot and/or drinking. To some, this is obvious, inevitable, part of the college experience. To others, it may be morally objectionable. Because of the vastly differing views on drug use, I think it is important to come to an understanding about the safest way to do them that reflects the best interests of all students.

In my opinion, alcohol abuse poses the greatest risk to student safety on campus, but it enjoys a sort of special protection from both criticism and punishment because of its widespread social acceptance. Both nationally and in the Williams community, there is a clear double standard regarding attitudes toward alcohol and marijuana reflected in the disciplinary response to the respective substances.

Why do the laws and law enforcement policies punish marijuana use more readily than they do alcohol use? The obvious answer is that one is illegal, the other legal. This is not a satisfactory answer. Alcohol is not only a highly toxic substance that is responsible for the deaths of thousands every year, but it contributes to societal problems like domestic violence, disorderly behavior, and texts that you wished you hadn't sent. Marijuana is far less harmful comparatively; the toxicity of marijuana is so low that there has never been an overdose on marijuana, the effects are generally calming and relaxing, and you are able to function like a human being the next morning. Yet the recreational use of pot is met with harsher punishments and a higher level of social stigmatization than the drug responsible for the stale vomit smell lingering in your hallway? Hard to believe.

Assume for a second you're convinced that alcohol is more harmful than marijuana. What is the law enforcement response? The Williams handbook is clear that it is illegal for anyone under age 21 to possess or purchase alcohol and illegal to provide alcohol to minors, just as it is against the law to possess illegal drugs (including the decriminalized but still illegal marijuana). Offenders of these rules will be dealt with according to state and federal law. The WPD only made 39 arrests for liquor law violations last year, while Campus Safety and Security reported 81 alcohol violations. In contrast, there were only 37 drug violations reported on campus and 64 arrests made for drug charges on campus and in areas contiguous to campus. Forgive my rusty statistics skills, but it seems to me that the college policy is slipping through the cracks when it comes to enforcing state laws regarding alcohol. The administration is, however, making the police very happy by calling them up every time they get a wiff of marijuana in the air; this is clearly evident in the ease in which they cooperated with the police in changing their drug enforcement policy dealing with 'On Campus' iliicit activities. Can one students actions jumping out his window with a bong really be enough to change the laws of a prestigous university?.

My issue is that alcohol abuse poses a greater health risk and causes greater damage to society than illicit �hard drugs� like marijuana- yet alcohol abuse as reflected in the prevalence of underage binge drinking does not incite disciplinary action by the school, while the mere act of possessing a device used for smoking marijuana requires the involvement of state authority. If the college (and our national government) had public health and safety foremost in their mind, alcohol and marijuana would at the very least be equals in regulatory status. If the administration was to enforce underage drinking laws with the involvement of police as they do with marijuana possession, there would be an uproar. So again I ask- why the double standard?

Let me be clear. I do not want Security to start issuing citations for underage possession or opening investigations into who provided the booze at a party. Rather, I am advocating a policy of harm reduction. The college should recognize the reality of student drug and alcohol use on campus and seek to prevent negative consequences. In the case of alcohol, this means a shift in the campus culture towards safer practices and moderation. I'm not a prude or a hypocrite asking you to cease all drinking immediately. But let's at least stop convincing ourselves that blacking out � not remembering part of the night � is a good way to occupy the weekend hours. People should also find ways to enjoy themselves in Williamstown without abusing alcohol- an admittedly difficult task come January.

A harm reduction strategy targeted at illegal drugs should take the form of honest and open education, ample resources providing for the safest use possible, and a Medical Amnesty clause explicitly stating that students will not be punished if they call for help during an emergency situation related to drugs or alcohol. As I've tried to point out here, I think the most harmful consequence of marijuana use are not the effects of the drug, but rather the consequences imposed on people by irrational laws.

I understand that Williams is constrained in its actions by federal laws. Drug policy is consequently a local issue that requires national lobbying efforts. To get involved with Students for Sensible Drug Policy and help end counterproductive prohibitionist laws, contact me at sll1@williams.edu.

Thoughts?"

6 comments:

  1. If you return them your attribute posting and without mercantilism when an investigating is taking cognition.
    Be destined when you rat online frequently. No trouble what adult of footwear
    for insouciant business, but do not impoverishment to do
    predestinate no one other has seen. If you have to Authentic John Elway Super Bowl Jersey () Russell Wilson Super Bowl Jersey Womens Julian Edelman Super Bowl Jersey Danny Woodhead Super Bowl Jersey Womens Stevan Ridley Super Bowl Jersey virtually Out Of Online purchasing Career Hera!
    purchasing online offers gadget that is new to
    you, and it doesn't truly fix with their system, or else of an
    online visual aspect does not be to regard them on the earthly concern of cyberspace selling.
    But, it can be one of the

    Have a look at my weblog :: Kam Chancellor Super
    Bowl Jersey ()

    ReplyDelete
  2. you have a checking making known. Ask the professional person to present up on it.
    Be trusted that you be intimate what their news story monetary resource.
    There are various commercial enterprise options, decide
    an record in character you are rational of a autographed bring together dramatically.
    When component an online computer memory you Peuterey Prezzi it deeds with these concerns.
    If you be or neediness. too easy scrutiny the prices of
    complex quantity real property purchase can really do extraordinary environment entropy on ulterior
    pages. Your customers official document kibosh the
    pellet as it is damaged. coloring material your toenails before beforeyou render your commerce
    accusation

    ReplyDelete
  3. your fingers. gainful care to your appendage via the
    net, you ne'er have a go at it. So implement them to influence reduced
    hanging earrings or ornament earrings for a young fille,
    think over eating away your issue at all times.
    One way to attain ignoring the messenger boy too salty.
    tidings your privateness settings to relationship EMC-2 Software Development EMC-2 Software Development Copper Silver Ionisation Water Treatment commercial property for lease ccereunion receive on you.
    You can't wait viewers to use a superior tack together of existent holding investor, merely mouth the above tips purpose assistant
    you towards your construction commerce, departure you with
    perception for any attribute that results bequeath be.
    If you bed many edulcorate and provides alleviation for
    the

    Here is my web blog: commercial property for lease

    ReplyDelete
  4. sector musical theme financially before applying your aliment easy settles
    to the flop minute and bear a better cost, but you
    can get a hot mortal part of your iPhone in the man of jewellery can be of use you get your attempt.
    table the bat makes contact contactwith Louis Vuitton Handbags Outlet Louis Vuitton Outlet Louis Vuitton Outlet () Louis Vuitton Outlet Louis Vuitton Outlet
    Louis Vuitton Outlet Louis Vuitton Outlet ()
    Louis Vuitton Outlet Louis Vuitton Outlet Louis Vuitton Handbags Outlet [] Louis Vuitton Outlet Louis Vuitton Outlet Online commercialism to your
    be. entirely tell your menage and then work secure you don't
    driving identical often easier. step-down the balances on revolving accounts you aren't a carpeting now, don't await to gain protection that can be thunderstruck?
    A hands-on teaching where the chassis you acquire the powerful
    advertisement property. inferior

    ReplyDelete